AI Law Consultancy

Artificial Intelligence, Algorithms, Machine Learning, Automated Decision Making, Data Protection and Human Rights

The use of Algorithms, Artificial Intelligence (AI), Machine Learning (ML) and Automated Decision Making (ADM) is growing incredibly fast in every aspect of life. In September 2020 it was reported that over 40% of enterprises across the EU27, Norway, Iceland and the UK, have adopted at least one AI technology, and a quarter have adopted at least two, yet huge uncertainty remains about potential damages, data standardisation and regulatory obstacles. In October 2021 Deloitte’s report on the “State of AI in Enterprise” showed no halt to this during the pandemic. So developers, regulators, government, business, trade unions, NGOs, end-users, and their lawyers need easy access to expert advice on the relevant legal rules.

code projected over woman

A difficult different discrimination: Artificial Intelligence and disability

The UN’s Special Rapporteur on the rights of persons with disabilities (SR) published a thematic report “A/HRC/49/52: Artificial intelligence and the rights of persons with disabilities” on 28 December 2021 calling on States, NGOs, National Human Rights Organisations and civil society in general to take a stand against Artificial Intelligence (AI) that harmed persons with Continue Reading

wavy ocean near coast under cloudy sky

A clear ruling from the Italian Supreme Court: Consent without transparency is legally worthless, especially where an AI system is used to assess credibility and reputation.

The blog has been co-authored with Alexandru Cîrciumaru. More information about Alex is available at the end of this blog. Introduction Perhaps no principle of law is more important than the right to personal autonomy, because, in human terms, without it we are nothing.   Personal autonomy means being able to give, or withhold, our real Continue Reading

bridge over river in city

The pandemic, social benefits, and automated decision making (ADM): Just because it is quicker to use a machine, is it consistent with the principle of non-discrimination?

Introduction On one level, it seems a very worrying idea that machines alone could be left to make important governmental decisions about our business, our personal finances or security.  No doubt, if those decisions “go our way”, we probably won’t mind too much about the process itself since quick welcome decisions will always be applauded.  Continue Reading

serious woman browsing smartphone near laptop

TUC report: Technology Managing People – the legal implications

Joshua Jackson, a pupil at Cloisters, discuss a report prepared by Robin Allen QC and Dee Masters for the TUC, which examines the legal implications of the use of AI in the workplace. In November 2020, I examined the TUC report (“Technology managing people: The worker experience” ) and CDEI report (“Review into bias in algorithmic Continue Reading

bikes parked on city embankment near canal and old buildings on cloudy day

An Italian lesson for Deliveroo: Computer programmes do not always think of everything!

In this blog we examine a very recent Italian decision from the Bologna Labour Court – Filcam VGIL Bologna and others v Deliveroo Italia SRL – which held that Deliveroo’s algorithm – called “Frank” – which determined its workers priority to access delivery time slots was discriminatory. Whilst we understand that the algorithm at the heart of that case is now defunct, there is an important lesson to be learnt from the decision. Specifically, this Deliveroo case demonstrates conclusively how unthinking reliance on algorithms simply because they are perceived to be “useful” can lead to unintended discrimination – with the result that a business ends up in court.

ancient architecture arena buildings

AI and foreign travel. Hoping to get away? Be prepared for the Border Bots.

The blog has been co-authored with Alina Glaubitz. More information about Alina is available at the end of this blog. Covid–19 has brought immediate changes to the rights of free movement in the European Union as each Member State has struggled to control the spread of the virus.  Temporary travel restrictions were introduced, and Brexit Continue Reading

Ethical uncertainty or legal certainty? The importance of regulating AI now.

We have been thinking hard about the best way to regulate AI since,  in addition to maintaining our online resource dedicated to AI, human rights, discrimination and data protection, our recent projects have included – Our view is that meaningful accountability for AI, will not come solely through ethical bodies or dedicated critical journalism, though Continue Reading

man and woman discussing and sharing ideas

“Algorithmic unfairness” & the recent ICO consultation

On 29 April 2020, we submitted a response to the ICO’s paper, “Guidance on the AI auditing framework: Draft guidance for consultation” (Draft Guidance). There were three points which we highlighted in our response as follows: In this blog, we will focus on the key theme of our response, namely the conflation of “algorithmic unfairness” Continue Reading

pile of books

French Parcoursup decision

On 3 April 2020, France’s Constitutional Council (Le Conseil Constitutionnel) handed down its long-awaited decision concerning the lawfulness of Parcoursup, a national algorithmic platform that assists educational establishments to select students and assign them to undergraduate courses in an equitable way.  Parcoursup had already been the subject of criticism by the Defenseur des Droits: see Continue Reading

bridge over river in city

Government automated-decision making

Over the summer of 2019, we were instructed by The Legal Education Foundation (TLEF) to consider the equality implications of AI and automated decision-making in government, in particular, through consideration of the Settled Status scheme and the use of Risk-Based verification (RBV) systems.   The paper was finished in September 2019 and ultimately, we concluded Continue Reading

Our blogs in this fast paced area can be accessed here.

Follow My Blog

Get new content delivered directly to your inbox.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.